Vietnamese Football and the Identity Question: When Winning Is Not Enough to Convince
Bóng đá Việt Nam đã đạt nhiều thành tựu nhưng vẫn thiếu bản sắc chơi bóng ổn định. Vấn đề nằm ở sự thay đổi huấn luyện viên liên tục, hệ thống đào tạo trẻ thiếu liên thông, chất lượng V.League chưa cao, và tư duy thành tích ngắn hạn. Để phát triển bền vững, Việt Nam cần chiến lược dài hạn, triết lý chơi bóng nhất quán, cải thiện giải quốc nội, khuyến khích cầu thủ ra nước ngoài, và sự đồng thuận từ lãnh đạo, truyền thông đến người hâm mộ. Bài học từ Nhật Bản, Hàn Quốc và Thái Lan cho thấy xây dựng bản sắc cần thời gian và kiên nhẫn.
In recent years, Vietnamese football has witnessed remarkable progress at both the national team and club levels. From the 2026 AFF Cup championship under coach Park Hang-seo to appearances in the third round of 2026 World Cup qualifiers, Vietnamese fans have grown accustomed to sleepless nights, nail-biting matches, and historic moments. Yet behind these dazzling achievements, a major question persists: Has Vietnamese football truly built a playing identity strong enough to survive the growing challenges of continental football? This issue is not merely about wins and losses on the pitch, but also about football philosophy, how we define success, and the limitations of a developing football nation.

- Undeniable Achievements
It cannot be denied that Vietnamese football has come a long way compared to two decades ago. If in the 2000s, getting past the SEA Games group stage or reaching the AFF Cup semi-finals was considered a success, expectations have now risen to a different level. The national team is currently ranked among the top in Southeast Asia, regularly qualifying for continental tournaments and producing matches on par with stronger, more experienced opponents.
At the club level, teams like Hanoi FC, Viettel, Hoang Anh Gia Lai, and Cong An Ha Noi have gradually established their positions in the AFC Cup and AFC Champions League. The trend of young Vietnamese players going abroad to Japan, South Korea, the Netherlands, or France is also a positive signal that youth development quality is improving. Academies like PVF, HAGL JMG, and Viettel's youth system have produced generations of technically gifted players with more modern football thinking.
These achievements result from a range of factors: more systematic investment from club owners, the professionalization of V.League, long-term youth development strategies, and especially the arrival of qualified foreign coaches. However, achievement and identity are two different stories. A team can win through character, luck, or individual moments of brilliance, but building an identity requires a system, a philosophy, and consistency over many years.
- The Identity Problem: When Playing Style Is Dictated by Opponents
One of the most common criticisms of Vietnamese football today is the lack of stability in playing style. At the national team level, every time a coach changes, the playing style seems to shift. Under Park Hang-seo, Vietnam played a disciplined, tight defensive counter-attacking style, maximizing opportunities. It was a style suited to the physical and technical characteristics of Vietnamese players and delivered good results. But under coach Philippe Troussier, the team tried to build a possession-based, more proactive attacking style — resulting in consecutive defeats in the 2026 World Cup qualifiers and a rift between the coach and players.

This story raises a big question: What is Vietnamese football looking for? An attractive, modern, possession-based style? Or a pragmatic, effective style suited to existing personnel? Both have merit, but the problem lies in this: without consistency and consensus from leadership to players, any philosophy can collapse after a few losses.
At the club level, the situation is no better. V.League was once praised as one of the most exciting leagues in the region, but the quality of play is uneven. Clubs frequently change coaches, foreign players, and tactics each season, meaning no team truly builds a distinctive playing style. Hanoi FC can be considered the team with the clearest identity through its technical, short-passing style, but even they struggle in continental competitions where physicality and speed are elevated.
- Structural Bottlenecks
To understand why Vietnamese football still struggles with the identity question, we need to look at structural bottlenecks. First, the youth development system, though improved, still lacks connectivity. Academies operate in their own ways, without a unified framework from U11 to U19. This leads to many young players taking a long time to adapt to a new playing style when they reach the first team, or wasting their talent because they don't fit the coach's tactics.
Second, the quality of the national league is not high enough to create real competitive pressure. The number of teams in V.League fluctuates frequently, with teams dissolving or being promoted and relegated repeatedly. This leaves players without a stable environment to develop and prevents coaches from building long-term plans.
Third, the financial issue. Although some clubs have more stable finances thanks to major sponsors, the overall standard of V.League remains low compared to regional leagues like Thai League or K League. This leads to good players tending to go abroad, while domestic clubs cannot afford to retain them or sign high-quality foreign players.
Fourth, and perhaps most importantly, is the mindset issue. Vietnamese football is still heavily influenced by short-term achievement thinking. Managers often prioritize immediate goals, leading to constant coach changes and instability in playing style and development strategy. Meanwhile, building a football identity requires time, patience, and high consensus.
- Lessons from Regional Football Nations
Looking at football nations in the region, the differences are clear. Japan is a typical example of building a sustainable identity. Since the 1990s, Japan has set the goal of becoming an Asian football power by building a systematic youth development program, encouraging players to go abroad, and maintaining a philosophy of possession-based, technical football. Japan's success does not come from a few wins, but from decades of perseverance along one path.
South Korea is another example. Although not as aesthetically pleasing as Japan, Korean football is famous for its fighting spirit, abundant physicality, and ability to press continuously. It is an identity built from culture and maintained across generations of players.

In Southeast Asia, Thailand has the clearest identity with its technical, short-passing, and attacking-minded style. Although Thailand has also experienced ups and downs, they have maintained a distinctive playing style that helps them sustain their regional position.
Vietnam can learn from these football nations, but cannot copy templates. Football identity must be built based on the characteristics, culture, and actual conditions of each country. Vietnamese players have advantages in technique, finesse, and quick adaptability. But they also have limitations in physique and stamina. Therefore, a playing style based on possession, quick combinations, and maximizing set pieces could be a suitable direction.
- The Role of Media and Fans
One factor that cannot be ignored in the identity story is the role of media and fans. In Vietnam, football is considered the king of sports, and every national team match attracts special attention from millions of people. This creates enormous pressure on players and coaches, while also generating expectations that may be unrealistic.
Vietnamese media often focus on results rather than process, on moments of brilliance rather than foundation-building efforts. This inadvertently contributes to an environment where winning or losing a single match can become the criterion for evaluating an entire football nation's capability. Fans also need to be educated to understand that building identity is a long-term process requiring patience and community support.
Of course, media and fans cannot be entirely blamed. Football managers need to take responsibility for clearly communicating their development strategy, long-term goals, and upcoming challenges. When fans understand the path the football nation is taking, they will have more trust and patience.
- What Direction for the Future?
To build a sustainable football identity, Vietnam needs a comprehensive, long-term strategy with high consensus. First, a unified youth development program must be built from grassroots to national team level, with a clear football philosophy maintained across generations of coaches. Second, V.League quality must be improved by upgrading infrastructure, enhancing management professionalism, and creating a healthy competitive environment. Third, players must be encouraged to go abroad to learn and improve, while creating conditions for them to return and contribute to domestic football.
Fourth, thinking about achievement must change. Instead of focusing only on short-term results, managers need to set long-term goals and stay committed to the chosen path. Fifth, exchanges and learning from advanced football nations must be strengthened, but with selective adaptation to Vietnam's conditions.
Finally, participation from the whole society is needed. Football is not just about players or coaches, but also about managers, sponsors, media, and fans. Only when all parties join hands can Vietnamese football build an identity strong enough to survive and develop sustainably.
Conclusion
Vietnamese football stands at an important crossroads. The achievements attained are admirable, but cannot be the stopping point. To go further, Vietnamese football needs a clear identity, a consistent football philosophy, and a sustainable development strategy. This requires patience, consensus, and effort from all stakeholders. Success will not come overnight, but if we know where we are going and how to get there, the path ahead will become clearer. Vietnamese football has proven that we can do extraordinary things. Now is the time to do the right things, sustainably and systematically.
